Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof in Pittsburgh
If you’re thinking about replacing your roof in Pittsburgh, you’re not alone. Many homeowners are facing the same dilemma stick with affordable shingles or invest in a long lasting metal roof. But there’s more to consider than just materials. Between aging homes, hidden wood rot, and costly gutter repairs, what starts as a simple roof project can spiral quickly. Before you spend thousands, read this breakdown of a metal roof vs shingle roof in Pittsburgh, and discover whether replacing the roof is the right move or if selling might be the smarter option.
Pittsburgh Homes Face Unique Roofing Challenges
Pittsburgh’s weather is hard on roofs. Ice, snow, high winds, and heavy rain can wear out materials quickly. Many homes in the area have aged roofing systems, and what’s under those shingles may surprise you rotting soffit, fascia damage, or deteriorating box gutters that are no longer functional.
Metal Roofs in Pittsburgh
Metal roofing is increasingly common across Pittsburgh, especially in renovated homes or modern new builds.
Why Homeowners Choose Metal Roofs
Choosing a metal roof in Pittsburgh isn’t just about aesthetics — it’s a long-term decision that appeals to homeowners looking for performance, durability, and peace of mind. Whether you’re dealing with heavy snowfall or intense summer heat, metal roofing delivers a range of benefits that traditional shingles can’t match.
Long lasting Durability
A high quality metal roof can last anywhere from 40 to 70 years, making it one of the longest lasting roofing materials on the market. While asphalt shingles often need replacement after 15 to 25 years, a metal roof can outlive multiple shingle roofs over a home’s lifetime. This makes it an attractive option for homeowners who plan to stay in their property long term or want to increase resale value with a premium upgrade.
Better for Extreme Weather
Pittsburgh winters bring ice, snow, and freeze-thaw cycles that wear down traditional roofs. Metal roofs shed snow easily, preventing the buildup of ice dams and heavy snow loads that can damage underlying roof structures. The interlocking panel system on most metal roofs also provides added protection against wind uplift during high storm events, making them one of the most weather-resistant options available.
Energy Efficiency
A metal roof is naturally reflective, bouncing back solar radiation rather than absorbing it like dark asphalt shingles. This means your attic and upper floors stay cooler in the summer, reducing air conditioning costs. In some cases, homeowners see energy savings of 10 to 25 percent annually depending on insulation and home orientation.
Low Maintenance
Unlike shingles that can crack, warp, or lose granules, metal roofing is largely maintenance free. It resists moss, mildew, insects, and fire, which means fewer headaches and fewer roof repairs over time. Annual inspections are typically all that’s needed to ensure it remains in excellent condition.
Environmentally Friendly
Most metal roofs are manufactured from 30 to 95 percent recycled materials and are 100 percent recyclable at the end of their life. Unlike asphalt shingles (which often end up in landfills) a metal roof supports sustainable building practices. Some systems can even be installed directly over an existing roof, reducing waste and tear-off costs.
What to Watch For with a Metal Roof
While the benefits are significant, there are a few considerations that come with choosing a metal roof.
Higher Upfront Cost
Installing a metal roof typically costs more than shingles. In Pittsburgh, the average cost ranges from 700 to 1,100 dollars per square (100 square feet), depending on the material (steel, aluminum, or copper), the roof’s pitch, and architectural complexity. Although the lifetime value is greater, the initial investment can be a hurdle for some homeowners.
Noise Considerations
A common concern with metal roofing is noise — particularly during rain or hailstorms. While this can be true for uninsulated structures like barns, modern residential metal roofs are typically installed with solid sheathing and attic insulation, which helps dampen sound. Still, if your attic has minimal insulation or venting, you may notice more ambient noise than with shingles.
Requires Experienced Installation
Installing a metal roof is not a DIY-friendly or generalist task. Improper installation can lead to leaks, buckling, or voided warranties. Make sure you hire a roofing contractor in Pittsburgh with specific experience in metal systems, proper flashing techniques, and manufacturer-certified training. This is critical to ensuring your metal roof performs to its full potential.
Also Read: How to Sell a Rental Property in Pittsburgh
Shingle Roofs in Pittsburgh
Asphalt shingles are still the most common roof in Pittsburgh due to their availability and lower cost.
Why Homeowners Choose Shingles
- Affordable: Costs range from 325 to 475 dollars per square installed.
- Easier to repair: Missing shingles are quick and inexpensive to replace.
- Widespread availability: Nearly every roofer installs shingles.
- Variety of styles: Blends in well with classic Pittsburgh neighborhoods.
Downsides to Shingles
- Shorter lifespan: Typically lasts 15 to 30 years.
- More vulnerable to damage: Can crack, curl, or blow off in wind or hail.
- Less eco-friendly: Made from petroleum based materials and not recyclable.
The Hidden Repairs: Soffit, Fascia, and Gutters
What many homeowners don’t realize is that older roofs in Pittsburgh often come with hidden costs. Years of trapped moisture or ice dams can lead to rotted soffit and fascia, which are structural components that support your gutters and roof edge.
If your home has box gutters (common in historic Pittsburgh homes) the problems can be worse. These built in gutters often leak and cause interior water damage. The best solution is to:
- Cover over the old box gutters with wood or aluminum trim
- Install modern aluminum gutters on the new fascia
- Reroute downspouts to improve drainage
This can add three to seven thousand dollars to a roofing project, depending on the home.
How Roof Size and Cost Are Calculated
Roofers typically measure in “squares,” which equals 100 square feet. For a standard 2,000 square foot home:
- Shingle roof: 6,500 to 9,500 dollars
Metal roof: 14,000 to 22,000 dollars or more
Most contractors now use tools like EagleView to generate a digital map of your roof. This software captures pitch, surface area, and angles making your quote faster and more accurate.
Also Read: Selling a Home That Needs Repairs in Pittsburgh
Metal Roof vs Shingle Roof in Pittsburgh: At a Glance
| Feature | Metal Roof | Shingle Roof |
| Lifespan | 40 to 70 years | 15 to 25 years |
| Upfront Cost | Higher | Lower |
| Energy Efficiency | Excellent | Moderate |
| Weather Durability | High | Moderate |
| Maintenance | Minimal | Regular |
| Appearance | Modern | Traditional |
Not Sure If It’s Worth Replacing the Roof?
If your roof needs major work and there’s fascia damage, box gutter issues, or old shingles curling up you may be facing 15,000 dollars or more in total costs. For some homeowners, selling the house as-is makes more sense than sinking money into repairs.
That’s where BuysHouses.co comes in. We buy houses in any condition throughout Pittsburgh, including those with old or damaged roofs. Whether you’re in Brighton Heights, Dormont, or Penn Hills, we’ll make a fair cash offer so you can avoid the hassle of costly contractors and delays.
Contact us today to get your no-obligation cash offer and find out if selling now is your best move.